The Impact of Patient Education with a Smartphone Application on the Quality of Bowel Preparation for Screening Colonoscopy
Article information
Abstract
Background/Aims
Few studies have evaluated the use of a smartphone application (app) for educating people undergoing colonoscopy and optimizing bowel preparation. Therefore, this study was designed to develop a smartphone app for people to use as a preparation guide and to evaluate the efficacy of this app when used prior to colonoscopy.
Methods
In total, 142 patients (male:female=84:58, mean age=43.5±9.3 years), who were scheduled to undergo a colonoscopy at Myongji Hospital, were enrolled in this study. Seventy-one patients were asked to use a smartphone app that we had recently developed to prepare for the colonoscopy, while the 71 patients of the sex and age-matched control group were educated via written and verbal instructions.
Results
The quality of bowel cleansing, evaluated using the Boston Bowel Preparation Scale, was significantly higher in the smartphone app group than in the control group (7.70±1.1 vs. 7.24±0.8, respectively, p=0.007 by t-test). No significant differences were found between the two groups regarding work-up time and the number of patients with polyps.
Conclusions
In this study, targeting young adults (≤50 years), the bowel preparation achieved by patients using the smartphone app showed significantly better quality than that of the control group.
INTRODUCTION
Colorectal cancer is the third most commonly diagnosed cancer worldwide [1]. Colonoscopy has been one of the most effective tools used for the detection of colorectal cancer [2]. A successful colonoscopy is dependent on the quality of bowel preparation [3]. Inadequate bowel preparation results in negative consequences for the examination, including missed lesions [4,5], procedural difficulties, and increase in overall colonoscopy cost [6]. Despite the importance of bowel preparation, up to 25% of all bowel preparations are considered as inadequate [7]. Inadequate bowel preparations are associated with old age, high degree of physical inactivity, previous failure to adequately prepare for a colonoscopy, and lack of adherence to instructions [8]. Although many previous researchers have evaluated interventions such as recommending a low residue diet, coordinating the timing of administration, and combining bowel cleansing agents, there still exists controversy about effective ways to educate patients about bowel cleansing [9].
It was announced that Korea’s smartphone penetration rate has reached 83 percent, putting the nation in fourth place when global smartphone use was ranked [10]. Moreover, in the future, the penetration of the smartphone is expected to experience a massive increase. Various educational applications (apps) are being prepared involving a number of health-related apps. There are many apps for patients suffering from diseases such as cardiovascular disease [11] and diabetes [12,13], apps which are effective in some ways for patient education.
However, despite the use of the smartphone as a common gadget, little information exists regarding the effect of the smartphone app in bowel preparation. To the best of our knowledge, there is no smartphone app for colonoscopy-related bowel cleansing in Korea. Therefore, the purpose of our trial is to develop a smartphone app for patients to use as a preparation guide for this procedure, and to validate the efficacy of bowel preparation when a smartphone app is used.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study design
This study consisted of two phases: an app development phase and a validation study.
Educational app development
To determine the contents of the smartphone app, the authors decided they should carry out an extensive review of other health-related educational apps and existing educational brochures and leaflets for colonoscopy. After determining the app contents, the design phase was implemented to specify learning objectives, contents, and the methods of educating patients about bowel preparation. Based on the analysis, an educational app was designed by Dr. Lee and Dr. Cho. Finally, Dr. Cho, one of the authors of this article who also works in the gastroenterology department at Myongji Hospital, developed the app.
The learning objectives comprised of the following 4 main sections: (1) Colonoscopy, (2) An example of poor bowel preparation, (3) Dietary recommendations, and (4) How to make and drink the bowel-cleansing agent. These objectives are shown in Fig. 1. This app was designed with the intention of informing patients about factors that are key to a successful colonoscopy (e.g., how to consume a liquid diet and perform bowel cleansing), according to the directions of the physicians.
A main screen calendar view of a smartphone with 5 sections consisting of the procedure explanation, usage method for the application, an example of areal case, explanations regarding the use of the oral bowel cleansing solution, and foods to avoid.
Unlike other apps used for colonoscopy bowel cleansing, the alarm time of this app is set at 3 days before the colonoscopy. To be concrete, each time (07:00, 12:00, 18:00) a patient eats a meal, the app lets them know the type of diet that is necessary to improve bowel cleansing. By simply entering the date of the colonoscopy in the app, the alarm function starts. In addition, it was thought that providing various examples of poor bowel preparation using visual animations and pictures could motivate the patients to effectively clean their bowels.
Main study
The second stage of this study was a prospective, endoscopist-blinded, matched, controlled study involving patients scheduled to receive colonoscopy at the gastroenterology department of Myongji Hospital in Korea. The study protocols were approved by the Institutional Review Board of Myongji Hospital, according to the ethical guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki (MJH14-015). This trial was registered with the Clinical Research Information Service (CRIS) at https://cris.nih.go.kr (KCT0001479).
The patients were asked to use a new smartphone app that educates the user on colonoscopy preparation, while the age and sex-matched (at 2-year age intervals) control group was educated using the existing verbal and written instructions. The patients in the smartphone group were educated about how to download the app onto their smartphones. The smartphone app assisted bowel cleansing by explaining the colonoscopy procedure, showing pictures of various examples of preparation quality, and explaining how to make the purgative solution. This app, which was designed for the Android operating system (OS), can be freely downloaded (Fig. 2).
Quick response code of the bowel preparation application.
All the patients were given the same bowel cleansing product—2 L of a solution containing polyethylene glycol (PEG) plus ascorbate (Coolprep®; Taejoon Pharm., Seoul, Korea). Three days before the colonoscopy, they were instructed to refrain from eating high-fiber foods, as well as foods containing seeds, sea algae, etc. On the day before exam, they were asked to eat a light dinner, followed by fasting, with the exception of drinking water. On the day of the procedure, they were requested to drink the cleansing product between 8 and 4 hours before the exam. All colonoscopies were performed in the afternoon. All the colonoscopies were performed by two board-certified, experienced endoscopists (Dr. Hong Sub Lee and Dr. Jeong Ho Kim), each of whom have performed more than 5,000 colonoscopies.
Subjects
Patients who were scheduled to receive a colonoscopy at Myongji Hospital were eligible for participation in the study. The inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) young adults (≤50 years old) who possessed an Android smartphone that they could skillfully use and (2) patients who signed the informed consent. The exclusion criteria were as follows: (1) patients with severe comorbidities (cardiovascular disease, chronic renal disease, etc.) who could not tolerate an endoscopic procedure; (2) patients with mental illness; (3) patients with an allergy to the PEG solution; (4) patients with a history of colorectal surgery; (5) patients with planned endoscopic therapy; and (6) patients who did not sign the informed consent.
Well-trained nurses employed at the gastroenterology endoscopy center provided the patients with education about bowel preparation. All the patients provided written informed consent before they participated in the study.
Determination of the sample size
In a previous study that provided patient education using animation [14], the average the Boston Bowel Preparation Scale (BBPS) scores of the control group (those who received standard education materials) and the study group (those who received animation-based education) were 6.1 (standard deviation [SD]=2.2) and 7.4 (SD=1.9), respectively. The number of patients in each group of present study was calculated to determine the results that would reflect a significance level (α) of 0.05 and a power of 0.90. Therefore, we calculated that 124 patients, including 62 patients in the intervention group and 62 patients in the control group, were needed. We chose to enroll more than 140 patients to allow for an approximate drop of 10%.
Outcome measures
The primary endpoint of this study was the quality of bowel cleansing. The quality of bowel preparation was evaluated using the BBPS [15]. Using this scale, the quality of bowel preparation was given a score of 0 to 3 for each of the three colonic segments (that is, left, transverse, and right). Finally, the total score was calculated, which ranged from 0 to 9 (higher scores mean better bowel preparation). The BBPS score was validated in Korea [16]. In such studies, it was reported that the polyp detection rate is higher in people with higher BBPS scores than in those with lower BBPS scores.
The secondary outcomes included cecal intubation time, withdrawal time, and the number of patients with polyps. The third outcome was the degree of satisfaction with the smartphone app for bowel preparation. The patients’ satisfaction was assessed with a questionnaire, which included the question, “Are you satisfied with the education delivery method for the preparation of a colonoscopy?”. The answer to the question was evaluated based on the10-point Likert scale (a 0 to 10 scale in which 0=“extremely dissatisfied” and 10=“extremely satisfied”), a scale commonly used to assess responses to survey questionnaires [17]. The 10-point scale in this study can detect subtle changes than a 7-point or 5-point scale. In addition, The Likert scale using the response points and markers is easier to understand, compared with the typical comprehension of a visual analogue scale.
Statistical analyses
Primary and secondary outcomes were assessed using Student’s t-test. Questionnaire responses were evaluated with the chi-square test. Analyses were performed with SPSS software V.14.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) for Windows. A p-value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. To minimize selection bias from lack of randomization, subgroup analysis by one-to-one propensity matching was performed using R Statistical Software 3.3.3 (The R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria). The covariates for matching estimation were age, gender, body mass index (BMI), previous abdominal surgery, history of hypertension, diabetes, and hypothyroidism.
RESULTS
Patients’ characteristics
From July 2014 through September 2015, 899 potential study participants were considered for this study. Among them, 757 patients were excluded for the following reasons: they failed to meet the inclusion criteria, they did not keep their procedure appointment, or they withdrew their consent for the procedure. Finally, 142 patients with a scheduled elective colonoscopy were enrolled. Seventy-one patients used a smartphone app that we recently developed, and the 71 patients of the sex and age-matched control group was educated using the existing verbal and written instructions.
Concerning the basic characteristics of the two groups (Table 1), mean age (app group: 42.3±10.3 years vs. control group: 44.8±5.4 years, p=0.107) and BMI (app group: 23.8±3.8 kg/m2 vs. control group: 24.3±3.8 kg/m2, p=0.447) were similar, but the number of patients with a history of a previous colonoscopy were significantly higher in the app group.
Demographic Data of 142 Participants
Outcomes of bowel cleansing
The mean BBPS scores in the smartphone app group were significantly higher compared to those of the control group (app group: 7.70±1.1 vs. control group: 7.24±0.8, p=0.007) (Table 2). Although the scores of the BBPS for the transverse colon were similar in both the groups, the scores for the left and right colons were significantly higher in the app group compared to those of control group.
Bowel Cleansing Scores Assessed by Boston Bowel Preparation Scale
Subgroup analysis of those without a history of previous colonoscopy was done, because previous experience of colonoscopy can be a serious bias. After one-to-one propensity matching for subgroup analysis, there were 37 patients in each group. Based on the previously discussed subgroup analysis, the mean BBPS scores in the app group were significantly higher compared to those of the control group (app group: 7.73±1.3 vs. control group: 7.16±0.8, p=0.031) (Table 3). However, the baseline characteristics including age, sex, history of abdominal operations, and BMI were significantly different between the two groups.
Subgroup Analysis Propensity Score Matching Using R Studio in Participants without Previous Colonoscopy
Procedure time and the polyp detection rate
There was no significant difference between the two groups with respect to the number of patients with polyps (app group: 23/71 vs. control group: 15/71, p=0.129) and there were no significant differences in the detection of a tubular adenoma between the two groups. In addition, there were no significant differences in the duration of work-up time (app group: 16.36±7.5 minutes vs. control group: 15.54±6.6 minutes, p=0.493), including the cecal intubation time, between the two groups.
Satisfaction
The patients’ satisfaction with the bowel preparation administered in both the groups was evaluated through a questionnaire. The mean score of the questionnaire was significantly higher in the app group than that of the control group (app group: 7.62±2.2 vs. control group: 5.97±2.2, p<0.001).
DISCUSSION
The purpose of this study was to develop a smartphone app for bowel cleansing and to validate the efficacy of the app. This is the first study to report the development and use of a smartphone app for bowel cleansing in the Korean language. In the present study, BBPS scores were significantly higher in the app group compared to those of the control group (app group: 7.70±1.1 vs. control group: 7.24±0.8, p=0.007), and the patients’ satisfaction scores was higher in the app group compared to those of the control group. A smartphone app can assist with bowel preparation by displaying text instructions, visual aids, and alerting the patients of time. Through the smartphone app, the patients can learn when the diet restrictions should start and they can be repeatedly reminded of the foods they should avoid. These could be possible explanations of how bowel preparation improved using the smartphone app.
Results of this study correspond well with those of an earlier study which reported that the use of a smartphone app, as a means of education, was associated with improved quality of bowel preparation [18]. That study reported improved bowel preparation and patient satisfaction with the use of a smartphone app, compared with that of the control group.
Some studies, which employed an education intervention using simple visual aids [18] or additional explanations [19], had no influence on the quality of bowel preparation in patients prior to colonoscopy [20]. However, other studies using visual aids such as a booklet [21,22] and an educational video [23,24], demonstrated that patient education can have a positive effect on bowel preparation. The possible reason for the mixed findings among many studies about education regarding bowel cleansing is just to stimulate temporary anxiety about poor bowel preparation to motivate bowel preparation compliance. On the other hand, the results of some studies demonstrated improvements in bowel preparation with the use of the telephone [25] and mobile phone messages [26] to reinforce diet instructions and timetables for ingestion of bowel preparation agents.
These studies suggest that education by more interactive and intensive methods may be needed to improve bowel cleansing. Therefore, the app presented in this study of bowel preparation is a method involving education by visual aids combined with a reminder function. This current study proves that a smartphone app can significantly improve bowel preparation for colonoscopy. This smartphone app is freely available on the Android OS market and anyone can download it. As of December 24, 2016, the download number had reached over 1,000.
In this study, the number of detected polyp was higher in those who used the smartphone app than those receiving written explanations, but not significantly different (app group: 23 vs. control group: 15, p=0.129). A higher polyp detection rate has been found in patients with adequate bowel preparation [8]. The reason to fail to show significant difference in current study may be attributable to a relatively small sample size. Studies employing other educational methods failed to show a significant difference in polyp detection rate [9]. Therefore, a large number of patients would be needed to discriminate the difference in the rate of polyp detection.
There are several limitations to this study.
First, a randomized controlled trial could not be done. The collection of patients was not easy because this app had not been validated. In addition, some people who were scheduled to receive a colonoscopy were afraid of using the smartphone app in place of written explanations. Since most people thought that a colonoscopy is a once-in-a-lifetime checkup usually performed for health screening and not for the evaluation of chronic disease, they were reluctant to learn how to use our app. Thus, there is a possibility of a selection bias. Also considering that the study involved patients with a history of previous colonoscopy, this could also affect the efficacy of bowel preparation. To reduce selection bias due to the lack of randomization, subgroup analysis using one-to-one propensity matching was done. Despite small differences in the bowel preparation scale scores, results of the subgroup analysis for patients without a previous colonoscopy suggest that bowel preparation by smartphone app is superior to written instruction. Additionally, further evaluation using a randomized controlled trial could be done safely without the risk of poor bowel preparation. Further studies using a more revised smartphone app that gathers feedback from its users could have better results than those of the current study.
Second, only smartphone users with an Android OS could participate in this study and other smartphone users could not participate in this study. An individual’s choice of smartphone varies based on different factors and may influence bowel-cleansing [27]. Therefore, the results of this study may not be applicable to the general population. However, according to a report of the International Data Corporation, which conducts American market research, the Android OS market share accounts for up to 86.8% of the global smartphone OS market share [28]. Furthermore, according to the report from the Korea Internet & Security Agency, the Android OS accounted for as much as 85.82% of the smartphone OS market share in Korea [29]. Although Android accounts for the majority of the smartphone market, there is a need to design an app with an iPhone-based OS in the future.
Third, this study was a single-center study and the number of people who participated in this study was small. Multi-center studies should be done to confirm the efficacy of a smartphone app for bowel preparation.
Fourth, an inclusion criterion of this study was that patients had to be less than 50 years old. Usually, a colonoscopy is recommended for patients aged 50 years and above and in this older age group, people are not as familiar with smartphone apps. Since the polyp detection rate in young people is increasing, tools for diverse education are becoming necessary.
In conclusion, this study reveals that bowel preparation, as assessed by the BBPS, performed with a smartphone app was significantly better than the quality of bowel preparation done by following written paper instructions. In addition, patient satisfaction with bowel preparation was significantly better in the group of patients using the smartphone app.
Notes
Conflicts of Interest:The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.
Author contributions
Conceptualization: Hong Sub Lee
Data curation: JeongHyeon Cho
Formal analysis: HSL
Funding acquisition: HSL
Investigation: SeungHee Lee, Jung A Shin
Methodology: HSL
Project administration: HSL
Resources: HSL
Software: JHC
Supervision: Jeong Ho Kim
Validation: HSL
Visualization: JHC
Writing-original draft: JHC, SHL
Writing-review&editing: HSL